Roofer Chicks New Braunfels Reviews
Roofer Chicks reviews, BBB record, and pricing for New Braunfels and San Antonio homeowners. On the same 3,110 sq ft roof, their estimator quoted $14,687–$22,338 — ours came in at $12,029–$13,174. Same shingle brands, though their Yelp page tells a different story.
Even their cheapest shingle costs more than our most expensive.
See My Instant Price
Roof Direct SA vs Roofer Chicks: side-by-side comparison
Based on publicly available information.
| Roof Direct SA | Roofer Chicks | |
|---|---|---|
| Same roof, same shingles (3,110 sq ft) | $12,029–$13,174 | $14,687–$22,3388 |
| Their cheapest vs. our best | $13,174 (OC Duration — lifetime warranty) | $14,687 (Malarkey Highlander — economy)8 |
| Online pricing | Front and center — instant price on the homepage | Buried estimator — site funnels you to a salesperson |
| BBB complaints | 0 complaints | 0 complaints1 |
| Sales team overhead | Zero salespeople | 5-person sales team2 |
| New Braunfels presence | Serves New Braunfels — 16 years in the area | New Braunfels HQ since 20164 |
| Specialization | Roof replacement only | Roofing, siding, gutters, windows, handyman5 |
Roofer Chicks reviews, BBB record and complaints
Roofer Chicks is a women-owned roofing company founded in 2016. They have zero BBB complaints and strong Google reviews. Their Yelp page (20 reviews) paints a more complicated picture. One homeowner reported paying $11,000 for a full roof replacement only to have a crew member urinate on a neighbor's home, landscaping destroyed, and the job left incomplete. Another customer's repair shingles fell off after just 13 months. A third described a simple repair that took over two months and five or six visits. Communication and difficulty reaching management are recurring themes. The owner responds to every review.
We take a different approach — no sales team, no commissions, no corporate overhead. Just your price, upfront, in 2 minutes.
Roofer Chicks pricing
What you're actually paying for — and what we eliminated.
Where Your Money Goes
Based on a typical 2,500 sq ft San Antonio roof
Materials and labor are identical. The difference is everything else.
Typical savings: ~$5,250
Sales team salaries
Roofer Chicks employs a Sales Manager, three sales reps, and an Appointment Coordinator — five people in the sales process before a single shingle is installed. We have zero salespeople. You see your price online in 2 minutes.
Brand and marketing overhead
Roofer Chicks invests heavily in brand marketing and media coverage. That builds recognition, but those costs factor into every quote. We spend nothing on advertising — the savings go directly to you.
Instant pricing, no appointment
Their site pushes you toward scheduling with a salesperson. We show your exact price in 2 minutes — no appointment, no home visit, no waiting.
Multiple service lines
Roofer Chicks offers roofing, siding, gutters, windows, doors, and handyman services. Running 6+ service lines means more overhead spread across every job. We do one thing — roof replacement.
With Roof Direct SA, your price is based on your roof size — not your zip code, not a sales commission, not whether you have an insurance claim. See your exact price in 2 minutes.
Roofer Chicks' quoting process vs. instant pricing
Getting a roofing quote shouldn’t feel like buying a timeshare.
- 1Call or submit a form on rooferchicks.com
- 2Appointment Coordinator schedules an in-home visit
- 3Sales rep visits your home to inspect the roof
- 4Sales rep presents options and provides a written quote
- 5Review the quote and decide
- 1Type your address — satellite measures your roof instantly
- 2Choose Good, Better, or Best — see your exact price
- 3Submit — we call to schedule your install
Frequently asked questions
Straight answers. No sales pitch.
Google: 350+ reviews, strong ratings. Their strongest platform by far.
BBB: A+ rating, 34 reviews (5/5 average), zero complaints.
Facebook: 4.8/5 stars, 96% recommendation rate (283 reviewers).
Yelp: 20 reviews — several complaints about communication, repair quality, and project management. One $11,000 job resulted in landscaping damage and an incomplete project. Another customer's repair fell apart in 13 months. A simple repair took 2+ months and 5–6 visits. The owner responds to every Yelp review. Zero BBB complaints is a strong signal — but the Yelp feedback is worth reading before you sign.
The question is whether you want to pay for a 5-person sales team, brand marketing overhead, and 6+ service lines — or get the same shingles and manufacturer warranties for thousands less.
Economy shingle:
Roofer Chicks: $14,687–$17,950 (Malarkey Highlander Nex)
Roof Direct SA: $12,029 (Owens Corning Supreme 3-Tab)
Architectural shingle:
Roofer Chicks: $18,277–$22,338 (GAF Timberline HDZ)
Roof Direct SA: $12,852 (Owens Corning Oak Ridge)
Impact-resistant shingle:
Roofer Chicks: $18,195–$22,239 (Malarkey Vista)
Roof Direct SA: $13,174 (Owens Corning Duration)
Even their cheapest shingle ($14,687) costs more than our most expensive ($13,174). The difference is overhead — a 5-person sales team, 6+ service lines, and a New Braunfels headquarters.
The difference is what you pay for installation.
Note: Texas does not require a statewide roofing license. The TDLR does not regulate roofing contractors.
Get your exact roof price
Same shingles. Same warranties. Get your exact price in under 2 minutes—no appointment, no salesperson.
Get My Instant Quote
Compare other New Braunfels roofers
Sources
- Roofer Chicks BBB profile: A+ rating, accredited since September 2016, zero complaints in the last 3 years, 34 customer reviews averaging 5/5 stars. [source]
- Roofer Chicks sales team: Megan Smith (Sales Manager), Courtney Rion, Adrian Medina, JP Moreno (Sales Reps), Jennifer Utley (Appointment Coordinator). (rooferchicks.com/team/, accessed March 2026)
- Roofer Chicks certifications: GAF Master Elite (top 2% nationally), Malarkey Emerald Premium Pro, Owens Corning, IKO, TAMKO, RCAT member, TRI certified. (rooferchicks.com, accessed March 2026)
- Roofer Chicks HQ: 808 W County Line Rd, New Braunfels, TX. San Antonio satellite office at 1999 Gulfmart St, Suite 534 — open Monday and Wednesday only, 9am–12pm. (rooferchicks.com, accessed March 2026)
- Roofer Chicks services: residential and commercial roofing, siding, gutters, windows, doors, and handyman division (added 2022). (rooferchicks.com, accessed March 2026)
- Roofer Chicks (formerly Feller Roofing) founded June 22, 2016 by Ami Feller. Rebranded to Roofer Chicks in 2021. Featured on Good Morning America (GMA3) July 14, 2023. [source]
- Roofer Chicks voted Best Roofing Contractor by New Braunfels Herald-Zeitung readers for 7 consecutive years. Facebook: 4.8/5 stars, 96% recommendation rate (283 reviewers). Google: approximately 350+ reviews.
- Pricing comparison based on the same San Antonio address (1206 Oak Path, San Antonio, TX 78258 — 3,110 sq ft roof). Roofer Chicks prices from their online estimator at rooferchicks.com/get-instant-quote. Roof Direct SA prices from roofdirectsa.com/estimate. Both retrieved March 21, 2026.
- Roofer Chicks Yelp page (listed as "Feller Roofing of New Braunfels"): 20 reviews. Multiple complaints about communication, repair quality, and project management from 2018–2021. [source]
*Pricing based on publicly available data from each company’s website as of March 2026. Actual pricing varies by roof size, materials, and condition. Contact each company directly for exact quotes.